5 Thoughts on the Colts Heading into Week 5

The Indianapolis Colts’ early-season trajectory remains perplexing as they enter Week 5 with a 2-2 record that defies expectations. After stumbling out of the gate with losses to Baltimore and Kansas City, the team turned things around with two narrow victories—though neither came against particularly strong opponents.

The Colts beat a Texans squad without star wide receiver Nico Collins at home, then edged a Washington Commanders team relying on its third-string quarterback. Despite those wins, Daniel Jones has struggled with costly turnovers, and the offense has lacked explosive plays.

Yet, the Colts still lead the NFL in rushing efficiency by expected points added (EPA), a bright spot in an otherwise inconsistent start. The team’s reliance on Jones, who earned a $90 million contract extension, adds pressure, especially after his high turnover rate persisted into 2026.

Fans and analysts alike debate whether benching him would be the right move, but the coaching staff appears committed to sticking with their franchise quarterback for now.

Up nextNFL· 8h ago

NFL Week 9 injury report: Micah Parsons returns to Packers practice, Rams lose Jaylen Watson for season