Photo via Yahoo Sports

Will Smith is in a slump, but benching him isn't an option for Dodgers

The Los Angeles Dodgers face a critical offensive dilemma as catcher Will Smith continues his postseason slump, batting just .053 with minimal impact at the plate. Despite his struggles—including a 1-for-16 performance in the NLDS and only two postseason hits in 16 at-bats—Smith remains irreplaceable behind the plate, where his defensive leadership has been instrumental.

Opponents are hitting .160 against the Dodgers this postseason, the lowest mark in baseball, underscoring his value in guiding the pitching staff. With backup catchers like Hunter Feduccia lacking postseason experience and Dalton Rushing sidelined by injury, manager Dave Roberts has ruled out any lineup changes, emphasizing Smith’s defensive contributions over his offensive shortcomings.

The team may explore shifting Smith’s position in the batting order, a move that worked for Shohei Ohtani when he was moved from the leadoff spot to cleanup, where he has since shown renewed offensive production.

Smith’s inability to contribute offensively has created a noticeable void in the Dodgers’ lineup, particularly in front of Ohtani, who has reemerged as a key offensive force. While Smith’s batting average is among the worst in the playoffs, his defensive excellence—including framing and pitch-calling—has kept the Dodgers’ bullpen in check.

Roberts acknowledged the challenge of balancing Smith’s offensive struggles with his undeniable defensive value, stating that lineup adjustments remain a possibility but not a guaranteed solution. The Dodgers’ reliance on pitching and Smith’s defensive prowess leaves them with few alternatives, even as his bat continues to fail in high-pressure moments.

Up nextMLB· 30m ago

Yankees news: Turning to the offseason