Photo via Awful Announcing

Alex Rodriguez completely misunderstands ‘Moneyball’ while praising Milwaukee Brewers

The Milwaukee Brewers’ second straight National League Championship Series appearance has reignited debates about modern baseball strategy, but Fox Sports analyst Alex Rodriguez’s take on their approach missed the mark entirely. The Brewers, who dominated the San Diego Padres in their Division Series and boast MLB’s best on-base percentage, elite defense, and top-tier bullpen, embody the original principles of *Moneyball*—prioritizing contact, small-ball tactics, and efficiency over raw power.

Yet Rodriguez bizarrely labeled them a ‘counter-Moneyball’ team, ignoring how their success aligns with the 2002 Oakland Athletics’ data-driven blueprint. His claim that their lack of home runs detracts from their greatness overlooks how the league itself has shifted back toward analytics-driven play, from shorter basepaths to restricted defensive shifts, all of which favor teams like Milwaukee that excel in the fundamentals Rodriguez seemed to overlook.

The confusion stems from a broader trend where commentators conflate analytics with any strategy that doesn’t rely on brute force. Rodriguez’s own 2009 Yankees championship team, for instance, led the league in home runs—a far cry from the Brewers’ disciplined, metrics-backed approach.

While baseball has evolved into a numbers-heavy game, even top analysts sometimes struggle to distinguish between the original *Moneyball* philosophy and its modern distortions, leaving fans to sift through the noise for the real story: how a team with a modest payroll can dominate through smarts and execution.

Up nextMLB· 9h ago

Los Angeles Dodgers-Milwaukee Brewers schedule for NLCS rematch