
The New York Mets face a critical decision at second base heading into 2027, as their recent moves and struggles have left the position in flux. Marcus Semien, acquired last offseason in a trade with the Rangers, was expected to provide elite defensive play and a resurgence at the plate after winning a Gold Glove in 2025.
However, his offensive production plummeted in 2026, with a 74 OPS+ ranking him among the league’s least productive everyday players, while his defense also declined sharply, landing him in the fifth percentile for overall defensive value. Semien’s hip issues early in the season may have contributed, but the decline was undeniable, leaving Mets president of baseball operations David Stearns non-committal about his future at the position.
Meanwhile, the team’s promotion of prospect A.J. Ewing to center field and the shifting of Juan Soto to left field have reshaped the lineup, but the second-base question remains unresolved as Semien’s contract carries a $26 million salary for 2027 and a $24 million luxury tax hit annually, complicating the team’s payroll flexibility.
Brett Baty has emerged as a potential long-term solution, with Stearns highlighting his late-season hot streak as evidence of his ceiling. Baty’s consistent performance could be the key to securing the second-base role, but the Mets must decide whether to invest in Semien’s potential rebound or pivot to a younger, more promising alternative.
With the 2027 season approaching, the choice will have significant implications for the team’s future direction and roster construction.

MLB · 4h ago
MLB · 20h ago
MLB · 1d ago
See all videos