Photo via Yahoo Sports

‘Oklahoma Fans, You’re Stuck’ — Paul Finebaum Labels John Mateer a ‘Complete Bust,’ Slams AD’s Decision To Extend Brent Venables’ Contract

Oklahoma quarterback John Mateer’s once-promising 2026 season has unraveled after a dismal Week 5 performance against Georgia, where he threw three interceptions in a 41–13 loss. The Sooners’ struggles have drawn sharp criticism from ESPN analyst Paul Finebaum, who called Mateer a “complete bust” and mocked Oklahoma fans for being stuck with athletic director decisions, including the recent contract extension for head coach Brent Venables.

Mateer’s play has sharply declined since a thumb injury midway through last season, when he was a Heisman frontrunner, and his current stats—66.1% completion, 883 passing yards, and a PFN QB Impact score of 68.6—rank him near the bottom nationally. Despite the setback, Venables has defended Mateer, praising his leadership and work ethic, though the quarterback’s inconsistency remains a major concern ahead of a critical showdown with No.

1 Texas next week.

Up nextCollege Football· 22m ago

UNC football at Pitt Panthers game info, streaming, betting