
The Philadelphia Phillies’ defensive struggles reached a critical point in 2026, as they finished last in defensive runs saved (-51) and ranked near the bottom in outs above average (-15), despite posting a mid-tier 80 errors (17th in MLB). Trea Turner, a cornerstone of the team, was the most glaring issue, committing 21 errors—tied for the league lead—and posting a -17 defensive runs saved mark, a steep decline from his strong 2025 performance.
His future position, likely shifting to the outfield, will be a major offseason topic as the Phillies weigh whether his offensive value justifies his defensive liabilities. Beyond Turner, Bryce Harper’s regression at first base and in the outfield, along with Alec Bohm’s -10 defensive runs saved, compounded the team’s defensive woes.
Even catcher J.T. Realmuto, despite a strong 81% success rate on pitch-framing challenges, showed continued decline behind the plate.
Rookie Justin Crawford flashed potential in center field but remains unproven, leaving the Phillies with few reliable options to shore up their porous defense. With postseason play highlighting the stark contrast between their defense and that of remaining teams, addressing these issues is critical—especially if the team plans to lean more heavily on pitching in the coming years.

MLB · 4h ago
MLB · 20h ago
MLB · 1d ago
See all videos