Photo via MLB.com

Where does Chicago's pitching staff stand after 5 bullpen-heavy games?

The Chicago White Sox’s unconventional bullpen-first strategy paid off in their first two postseason games, but the approach faltered in Game 3 of the ALDS, forcing a tactical reset ahead of Thursday’s Game 4. With their entire high-leverage bullpen now rested—including closer Grant Taylor, who recorded saves in Games 1 and 2—the team can deploy its full arsenal.

Taylor, who hasn’t pitched since Monday, could return for a multi-inning role, while flamethrower Jordan Hicks (four scoreless postseason innings) and veteran Erick Fedde are also available for extended relief. Manager Will Venable emphasized flexibility, noting that Noah Schultz’s strong middle-relief performance in Game 3 gives the staff a fresh opportunity to reassess their options, though lefty Anthony Kay remains untested after struggling in Game 2’s opener.

The White Sox’s Game 3 struggles highlighted their reliance on short relief, as rookie Sean Newcomb and Tyler Hudson combined for just one inning before the offense stalled. Rookie right-hander Dylan Smith, who had excelled in earlier postseason starts, surrendered a game-changing three-run triple to Cleveland’s Jo Adell, while the bullpen’s early exits left the team scrambling.

Despite the setback, the White Sox’s depth—including rested arms like Smith (21 pitches in Game 3) and Sean Newcomb (22 pitches)—positions them to counter Cleveland’s rookie sensation Parker Messick, who will start Game 4. The team’s starter for Thursday remains unannounced, but their willingness to mix and match pitchers suggests they’ll continue prioritizing adaptability over tradition.

Up nextMLB· 28m ago

Ronald Acuña Jr. flails as Braves fall to Dodgers, and difficult questions are coming in Atlanta: 'I did nothing to help the team'