
The New York Mets' acquisition of Tobias Myers from the Milwaukee Brewers ahead of the 2026 season has not panned out as hoped, with the left-hander struggling significantly in his first year with the team. Myers, who had compiled a solid 3.15 ERA and 3.92 FIP across two seasons in Milwaukee—both as a starter and reliever—posted a dismal 5.53 ERA and 4.65 FIP in just 53.2 innings with the Mets this year, marking his worst performance by a wide margin.
His season was further complicated by frequent demotions to Triple-A Syracuse, where he spent much of the year bouncing between the majors and minors, a move that likely exacerbated his inconsistency. The Mets' handling of Myers, including his option to Syracuse in late May, raises questions about their approach to managing pitchers who falter early in the season.
With Myers still under team control through 2030 and his final option year used this season, he appears locked into the Opening Day roster unless the Mets make a significant bullpen overhaul or trade him—a scenario deemed unlikely given the current roster construction. The decline of both Myers and Freddy Peralta, another key addition from the Brewers trade, underscores the challenges the Mets face in integrating pitchers who had previously thrived elsewhere.

MLB · 5h ago
MLB · 21h ago
MLB · 1d ago
See all videos