College Football

John Mateer agonized over Texas loss. A year later, he's Oklahoma's hero in upset win

October 11, 2026

John Mateer’s journey from a demoralizing loss to Texas last season to a clutch hero in this year’s rematch underscores the weight of the Red River Rivalry. After a rocky start to 2026—including a 41-13 defeat to Georgia where he turned the ball over three times—Mateer faced skepticism about his starter role heading into Saturday’s showdown against No.

1-ranked Texas. Yet, in a game where Oklahoma trailed and the Longhorns dominated possession (382 yards to 238), Mateer delivered two game-saving throws to Isaiah Sategna in the final minutes, setting up Tate Sandell’s game-winning 47-yard field goal.

His 18-of-26 passing for 155 yards and no touchdowns belied the impact of his poise under pressure, as Oklahoma’s defense—highlighted by a 42-yard pick-six from Peyton Bowen and a late interception by Courtland Guillory—turned the tide in a 27-24 upset. The victory marked a turning point for Mateer, who had been a focal point of criticism for his decision-making this season, including a booed exit after a 14-6 win over New Mexico.